Q. When I file bankruptcy, can I just schedule the creditors
that I want to go bankrupt on?
A. No, you may not. Texas is a community property state,
therefore, all of your spouse's creditors must also be scheduled if you file a
bankruptcy petition solely for yourself. Of course, if you and your spouse file
a joint petition, all of your combined creditors must be scheduled.
Q. Are student loans dischargeable in bankruptcy?
A. Government backed student loans (which seem to be the
majority of all student loans) are not dischargeable in any type of bankruptcy
unless it can be shown that excepting them from discharge would impose an undue
hardship on the debtor or his or her dependents.
This can be determined, after you file bankruptcy, by means of a law suit
brought in the bankruptcy court.
You would have to show the court, that based on your present and prospective
income, you could not possibly pay back the school loan, at least without
extreme sacrifice to you and your family.
Q. I am in arrears with mortgage payments on my residence;
can I file some type of bankruptcy that would prevent a foreclosure?
A. Yes, if you qualify to file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy and
your income is sufficient to fund a Plan that provides for full payment of your
mortgage arrearages within a reasonable time which is five years in the Western
District of Texas, San Antonio Division.
Payments on the arrearages are made through the Chapter 13 plan through the
Chapter 13 Trustee's office.
You would also have to make your regular monthly mortgage payments directly to
the mortgage company.
Q. I am not behind with mortgage payments on my home but I
have substantial equity in it; would my home be sold if I file bankruptcy?
A. The home would only be sold in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case
by the trustee if the equity is in an amount greater than the exemption.
In Texas, debtors may choose between the State of Texas Exemptions or the
federal bankruptcy exemptions; but the two cannot be mixed.
Even if the equity is greater than the exemption, the trustee might not sell the
residence if the amount coming into the bankruptcy estate is of too little value
to administer.
In a Chapter 13, the debtor may voluntarily sell the home after obtaining court
approval.
Q. Can my bankruptcy discharge me from federal income tax
liability?
A. A discharge under a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, following the
successful completion of plan payments, will relieve the debtor from all income
tax liability and related penalties.
However unsecured 'priority' income tax must be paid at least 100% under the
Chapter 13 plan.
Priority income tax includes (but is not limited to) income tax for which a
return was due subsequent to three years before the filing of the bankruptcy.
Non-priority unsecured income tax would be paid under the plan on a par with
other general unsecured debt (such as on credit cards).
Unsecured tax penalties may be paid on such basis or nothing under the plan.
A discharge under Chapter 7 would not relieve you from liability for priority
income tax and certain non-priority income tax such as for tax years for which a
return has not been filed or was filed within 2 years prior to the filing of the
bankruptcy.
Penalties on these taxes are also non-dischargeable unless imposed for a tax
year ending prior to 3 years before the filing of the bankruptcy.
The remaining income tax/penalty liability is dischargeable under a Chapter 7
but nonetheless would be collectible (except possibly a penalty portion) to the
extent secured at the time the bankruptcy was filed.
If any income tax and penalty is secured by a valid perfected tax lien, such
lien (with certain exceptions) would remain following a Chapter 7 discharge but
would be gone following successful completion of plan payments and a discharge
under a Chapter 13.
In a Chapter 13, such lien would have to be paid in full, with interest, to the
extent of the security.
Q. What debts are not dischargeable in bankruptcy?
A. In a Chapter 7 case, most debts are generally
dischargeable. The most common type of debt that is not dischargeable is that
incurred by the debtor by certain fraudulent means.
That is, for example, where a debtor charges amounts to a credit card prior to
bankruptcy and without an intent to repay the charges.
Such lack of intent to pay may be evidenced by the debtor's filing the
bankruptcy within a short time following the incidence of such charges.
Another example of a debt made non-dischargeable by fraud is that incurred by a
debtor on a credit card obtained by application that sets forth the debtor's
income in an amount that is much greater than it really is.
If the credit card company can prove it would not have issued the card had it
known the debtor's true income, the charges run up on the card would be
determined to be non-dischargeable.
In these fraudulent instances the relevant debt, however, is dischargeable
unless the creditor timely files a complaint with the bankruptcy court and
proves the required elements of the fraud.
Other non-dischargeable debts in a Chapter 7 case that are dischargeable unless
the elements are proven pursuant to a timely complaint are: willful and
malicious injury (e.g. when a debtor refuses to give back a leased automobile to
the owner after defaulting on the payments and demand for its return, injuries
arising from a battery committed by the debtor) and certain types of fiduciary
fraud.
The above non-dischargeable debts are always, however, dischargeable in a
Chapter 13 (although the Court may dismiss a Chapter 13 for bad faith if a major
fraud is being perpetrated by the debtor).
Of course in a Chapter 13 proceeding, unsecured creditors may receive a
distribution from the trustee.
In addition there are a host of debts that are not dischargeable in a Chapter 7
without the necessity of the creditor filing a complaint.
These include alimony and child support, student loans in most instances and
injuries resulting from driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs - all of
which are likewise not dischargeable in a Chapter 13, and certain income tax.
The above list of non-dischargeable debts and illustrations are not exhaustive.
NOTE: Discharge has a special meaning in
the bankruptcy context. A discharge under bankruptcy relieves the debtor from
all personal liability as to dischargeable debts.
But take important NOTICE that a creditor
with a security interest on the date of the filing of the bankruptcy petition
securing payment of a debt can still, after the bankruptcy case closes, pursue
enforcement of the balance of the debt to the extent only of foreclosing on the
security in accordance with state law.
In a Chapter 13 it should be NOTED that
certain secured debt may be paid to the extent of the value of the security;
after discharge following plan completion the secured claim is considered paid
in full.
Q. What is the process after the petition is filed and how
much time does the bankruptcy process take?
A. In a Chapter 7 case, the First Meeting of
Creditors takes place about five to six weeks after the petition is filed.
If all goes well and there are no contests or adversary actions filed, the
discharge takes effect about five to six months from the date the petition is
filed.
In a Chapter 13 the discharge takes place after the Plan is completed, which is
generally between 3 to 5 years after the filing of the petition.
In any event after a bankruptcy is filed and prior to the discharge, the
automatic stay is in effect preventing most creditor activity.
Q. What happens to my automobile or pickup truck lease or
loan after I file bankruptcy?
A. In a Chapter 7 case an automobile lease will most likely be
'rejected' by the trustee. Under the terms of the lease the leasing company
might be able to terminate the lease because of your filing bankruptcy whether
or not you were then in default and such a clause would be effective as to you.
In such case the leasing company could pick up the motor vehicle when the
bankruptcy case closed or sooner under certain instances. If the payments to the
leasing company are current on the petition date, the leasing company might do
nothing and you could keep the motor vehicle.
If you should default on the lease after your bankruptcy closes the leasing
company might repossess the car but your liability would (if there is no
reaffirmation agreement) be limited to the reasonable rental value subsequent to
the filing of the bankruptcy.
In a Chapter 13 you could 'reject' the lease under the Plan, immediately return
the car to the leasing company which would then have a claim for breach of
contract to be paid under the plan (but you would also have administrative
reasonable rent liability for the period of time you held onto car after the
bankruptcy was filed).
You could assume the lease under the Plan which would have to provide for your
maintaining the regular lease payments. Any pre-bankruptcy filing default would
then have to be promptly cured.
As to a secured automobile loan in a Chapter 7, if you were not in default and
the trustee did not wish to sell your auto (which he would not do if there is no
equity greater than your exemption) you could keep the motor vehicle which would
however remain as collateral for the loan.
However in such instance any personal liability on this loan would be eliminated
by your bankruptcy discharge (unless the loan is reaffirmed).
This means that if you failed at some future point to make payments on the motor
vehicle, other than for moneys generated by the lender's sale of the motor
vehicle, the lender would have no recourse against you.
Such a discharge would have the same effect if you had been in default at the
time you filed the bankruptcy.
Of course if you were then in default the lender would be entitled to possession
of the car and could take possession of it after the case closes or sooner if
relief from the automatic stay is obtained.
Whether or not you are in default at such time the lender may require you to
file a reaffirmation agreement as a condition to maintaining possession of the
auto; such an agreement would keep the personal liability intact.
The legitimacy of this if you are then in default is, of course, totally proper,
but, if you are not, it is subject to argument.
In a Chapter 13 proceeding the loan on the motor vehicle would be paid pursuant
to the Chapter 13 Plan.
Q. I am operating a business and having a problem paying the
bills, what are my options?
A. If the business is owned by you or with your spouse and not
indirectly by way of a partnership, corporation or LLC, you may be able to
reorganize under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code or even possibly under
Chapter 13 of the Bankruptcy Code.
If you just want to get out of the business altogether you might be best in a
Chapter 7 liquidation. A Chapter 11 is expensive and there are substantial
requirements imposed by the Court and U.S. Trustee's office in order to keep
that kind of a Case going.
A Chapter 13 proceeding, on the other hand, is a quite a bit simpler and much
less expensive and has other benefits over a Chapter 11 especially with respect
to taxes you may owe the government (Federal and State) and other debts
(including those incurred by way of misrepresentation) that are not
dischargeable in a Chapter 11 or Chapter 7 but are in a Chapter 13 where full
payment thereon may not be required.
Chapter 11 and 13 contemplate the confirmation of a Plan by which creditors are
paid something while your business continues in operation. As long as you abide
by the appropriate rules you can continue your business operation prior and
subsequent to Plan confirmation.
If the business is owned by way of a partnership, corporation or LLC, Chapters 7
and 11 are available but Chapter 13 is not. It becomes a question of liquidation
vs. reorganization.
However a Chapter 7 proceeding will not result in the corporation receiving a
discharge but will result in an orderly liquidation of assets and hopefully
payment of any trust fund taxes (as priority claims) relieving corporate
officer/major shareholders from liability for '100% penalty assessments' as
imposed on them for payment of such taxes.
Q. I/ my company/ partnership lease premises where I/ the
company/ partnership conducts business. The rent is several months in arrears.
There is other business debt which would take a great deal of time to pay off.
Will bankruptcy allow the lease to stay intact?
A. Despite your predicament with the rent you may still be
able to successfully reorganize and maintain the existing tenancy under a
Chapter 11 or 13 if the business is owned by an individual, or Chapter 11 if the
business is owned by a corporation or partnership (where you may be a
shareholder or partner respectively).
To keep the lease intact the individual or entity filing the Chapter 11 or 13
must pay the rent as it becomes due after the filing of the case and must assume
the lease which necessitates the curing of any pre-bankruptcy default thereunder
within a prompt period (i.e. about three to six months).
Sometimes however the lease has been terminated (because of the tenant's
default) prior to the filing of the bankruptcy in which case it cannot be
assumed unless, possibly and arguably, under non-bankruptcy law (i.e. state law)
there is some anti-forfeiture law that is applicable and can be utilized. Lease
defaults, it should be noted, are, in many instances, a stumbling block to
successful reorganization.
Rent is, in a sense, the most important obligation that needs to be paid.
Q. What do I need to bring with me to the consultation with
the attorney?
A. We usually conduct the initial interview over the telephone
to determine whether bankruptcy would be in the client's best interest. If so,
we invite the client in for an office consultation. For the purpose of the
in-office interview, please gather and bring with you the following:
-
A recent statement or bill from every creditor. [A creditor is everyone to
whom you owe money; this includes, but is not limited to, credit card
companies, mortgage company, automobile and truck finance companies, the
Internal Revenue Service, medical providers, education loan companies,
school and county taxing authorities.
-
Your last two years' federal income tax returns.
-
The most recent month's wage statements from your employer. If you are
self-employed, you will need to provide evidence of your typical gross
income and business operating expenses.
-
Checking account bank statements for the most recent three to six months.
If you are self-employed, monthly operating statements.
-
Deeds to real estate if you own or are purchasing real property other than
your home in the city.
-
Documentation to any other kind of financial obligation that you have.